I tend to look at recipes based on the chefs from TV. I love, love, love Maria Batali (one of my
most memorable eating experiences was at Babbo in NYC) but I find his recipes a
little complicated or use ingredients that I don’t often use. Paula Deen is a favorite, but her way of
cooking is my way of cooking - there isn’t much difference in the regional
cooking of the south and of Appalachia and the Midwest – my cooking roots.
When I want to cook seriously I crack open Julia Child and
when I want to frustrate myself I look to Martha Stewart. It’s not that I don’t appreciate her skills,
but she seems to assume that we all have endless time and money to achieve success.
So it was with a little apprehension that I decided to make
a Martha Stewart punch recipe for a Desert Stream BBQ we were having at our
house. After all, its punch, how hard
can it be? In truth, it wasn’t very
hard, everyone liked it, and the punch was empty. In this case, it wasn’t Martha that was the
problem, it was me.
I decided that the thing this punch needed was an ice
ring. It was a very hot day in Kansas
City, I knew the punch would need a lot of ice and I didn’t want to water down
the punch. Martha recommended filling
ice cube trays with punch, but for once, I thought I could out do Martha.
So I made the punch, but with quite a few modifications:
Strawberry Punch a la Martha
·
4 cups water
·
3 cups sugar
·
6 cups coarsely chopped strawberries
·
2 cups coarsely chopped pineapple
·
1 cup pineapple juice
·
1 cup orange juice
·
1 cup freshly squeezed lemon juice
·
2 quarts seltzer water
Instructions
1. Make simple syrup: Combine the water and sugar in a large
saucepan, and bring to a boil over medium-high heat. Cook 5 minutes. Remove
from heat, and set aside until syrup is completely cool.
2. Transfer syrup to a large container. Add strawberries,
pineapple, pineapple juice, orange juice, and lemon juice; gently stir to
combine. Fill two ice-cube trays with punch, and place in freezer. Place
remaining punch in refrigerator to chill.
3. When ready to serve, remove punch from refrigerator; add
the seltzer water and frozen-punch ice cubes. Serve in a large bowl or
individual glasses.
My changes: I used canned pineapple – I know that Martha
always goes fresh and I usually do as well, but cutting up a whole pineapple
for just two cups seemed a little bit too much for me.
I didn’t want all that fruit floating in my punch, it didn’t
seem that pleasing to take a sip and get a piece of strawberry and pineapple. I decided to take all the fruit and combine
with the sugar and water to make strawberry/pineapple simple syrup. I combined the strawberries and pineapple
together and mashed them into a thick pulp.
I then added the sugar and water. After it had boiled the 5 minutes and
cooled I then poured the whole mixture into a fruit sieve into my punch
bowl. I had thick strawberry/pineapple
syrup with no fruit pieces.
After I added the pineapple, orange and lemon juices I
poured enough punch to fill a 6-cup Tupperware Jell-O mold to make an ice
ring. THIS WAS MY BIG MISTAKE! I have a great Jell-O mold but don’t have the
lid. I put the punch in the top shelf of
my bottom load freezer. Of course I
cautioned Sam to be really careful if he got ice, but didn’t think to say
anything to Andy since he never uses ice.
Did I mention how hot it was that day?
Well, I have a freezer to covered with frozen strawberry syrup to prove
Andy does us ice on a hot day.
The worst part – you really couldn’t even see the ice ring –
it was too heavy and sank to the bottom.
So score one for me – I think the punch was much better by
making the simple syrup with the strawberries and pineapple.
Score one for Martha – filling the ice trays with the punch
would have worked just as well and saved me a couple of hours cleaning my
freezer.
The moral of this for me is not to make an ice ring until I
find the lid to my Jell-O mold! But this
would be a great punch for the 4th of July – it’s very refreshing on
a hot day and goes with BBQ.






